No Bake Reeses Cup Peanut Butter Pie - Food, Fun, and Happiness

No Bake Reeses Cup Peanut Butter Pie

No Bake Reeses Cup Peanut Butter Pie ~ It's as easy as whipping up peanut butter with cream cheese and whipping cream. Mix in some Mini Reeses Cups. Refrigerate. And serve.

No Bake Reeses Cup Peanut Butter Pie
  • 8 oz cream cheese, at room temperature
  • 3/4 cup powdered sugar plus 2 tablespoons, divided
  • 1 cup creamy peanut butter
  • 1 cup heavy whipping cream
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 1 pre-made pie crust
  • Mini Reeses Peanut Butter Cup for garnishing

Prepare pie crust according to instructions. Alternatively, you can use the pie crust recipe in the video below. It looks tasty. Lastly, just keep in mind that only the recipe for the pie is used, again because I used a pre-made pie crust.

Using a stand mixer and a medium bowl, make peanut butter cream cheese filling by adding cream cheese, 3/4 cup powdered sugar and peanut butter. With a beater scraper, mix until creamy.

Using a second bowl, pour heavy whipping cream with 2 tablespoons powdered sugar and vanilla extract. Use whisk attachment and whip until fluffy.

Make the complete pie filling by combining whipped cream into cream cheese bowl. Manually fold it in using a spatula. It's best to pour whipped cream a little at a time while folding. Continue until filling is creamy, smooth and well-combined.

Pour filling into pie crust. Freeze or refrigerate for 4 hours or until solid enough to your liking. Garnish with mini reeses peanut butter cups while freezing.


The filling is from this video. Very easy to follow.

Is This Helpful? Then Share...


4th of July acne alfredo sauce appetizers apple asian asparagus avocado baby back bacon baked baking baking school banana banana bread banana cake bananas barbecue bars bbq beans beef beef fried rice beef pot pie biscuit black bean blackberry blackheads blueberry bread bread bowl breakfast broccoli brownie brunch burrito butter buttercream butternut squash cabbage cake cakes casserole ceviche cheeese cheese cheese cake icing cheesecake cheeze chicken chicken wings chickpeas chili chocolate chocolate chip chorizo churros clam chowder cocoa coffee coffee cake cold coleman cookies cooking school copycat cottage cheese crabs cream cheese creamy crescent rolls culinary school cupcakes curry dark chocolate decoration dessert desserts dip drinks Easter eggplants eggs enchiladas fajitas filipino fish flan flourless food french onion french toast fries frittata frosting fruits fudge garbanzo beans garlic gourmet gravy green beans grill grilled grilling ground beef habanero halloumi halloween ham hashbrowns healthy heart holidas holidays hummus Independence Day indian jalapeno kabobs kale kielbasa latin lechon leftover legumes lime low calorie macaroni main dish mango marinade marsala meat pie meat sauce mexican microwave milk mousse muffin muffins mushroom mushrooms nachos no bake noodles nutella oatmeal oats olive garden olives onions oreo cookies palabok pancakes pancit party food pasta pasta primavera peach peanut butter pepperoni peppers pies pig pimples pizza pork potato potato chips pretzels product review pumpkin quinoa raspberry recipe recipe ideas red velvet reeses ribs rice roadtrip lxe roast salads salami salmon salsa salted caramel sandwich sausage school seafood shepherds pie short ribs shortbread side dish slow cooker smoothies snacks soup sourdough spaghetti spanish rice spicy spinach splenda St Patrick's Day stew stir fry strawberry stuffing summer sweet potatoes tacos tangy tarty tater tots thanksgiving tilapia tiramisu toffee toffee cake tomato tomatoes tortellini tortilla treats turkey twix valentines vanilla vegetable vegetables vegetarian veggie walnut west bend whipped cream wraps zucchini
Toggle Footer